AcidBase: Indicators

Skills to develop

Explain color changes of indicators.
Determine the acidic dissociation constants K_a or K_ai of indicators.

Indicators

Indicators are substances whose solutions change color due to changes in pH. These are called acid-base indicators. They are usually weak acids or bases, but their conjugate base or acid forms have different colors due to differences in their absorption spectra.

Do you know that the color of hydrangea flower depends on the pH of the soil in which it is grown? This picture shows various colors of hydrangea flowers.

Indicators are complicate organic weak acids or bases with complicated structures. For simplicity, we represent a general indicator by the formula HIn, and its ionization in a solution by the equilibrium,

HIn = H⁺ + In^-, and define the equilibrium constant as K_ai,

        [H⁺][In^-]
  K_ai = ----------.
         [HIn]

Which can be rearranged to give

    [In^-]     K_ai
   ------- = -----
    [HIn]     [H⁺]

When [H⁺] is greater than 10 K_ai, In^- color dominates, whereas color due to HIn dominates if [H⁺] < K_ai / 10. The above equation indicates that the color change is the most sensitive when [H⁺] = K_ai in numerical value.

We define pK_ai = - log(K_ai), and the pK_ai value is also the pH value at which the color of the indicator is most sensitive to pH changes.

Taking the negative log of K_ai gives,

                           [In^-]
  -log K_ai = -log[H⁺] - log------
                           [HIn]
or 
                 [In^-]   
  pH = pK_ai + log-----
                 [HIn]

This is a very important formula, and its derivation is very simple. Start from the definition of the equilibrium constant K, you can easily derive it. Note that pH = pK_ai when [In^-] = [HIn]. In other words, when the pH is the same as pK_ai, there are equal amounts of acid and base forms. When the two forms have equal concentration, the color change is most noticeable.

Colors of substances make the world a wonderful place. Because of the colors and structures, flowers, plants, animals, and minerals show their unique characters.

Many indicators are extracted from plants. For example, red cabbage juice and tea pigments show different colors when the pH is different. The color of tea darkens in a basic solution, but the color becomes lighter when lemon juice is put into a tea. Red cabbage juice turns blue in a basic solution, but it shows a distinct red color in an acidic solution.

Some Common Indicators

Name Acid Color pH Range of
Color Change Base Color
Methyl violet Yellow 0.0 - 1.6 Blue
Thymol blue Red 1.2 - 2.8 Yellow
Methyl orange Red 3.2 - 4.4 Yellow
Bromocresol green Yellow 3.8 - 5.4 Blue
Methyl red Red 4.8 - 6.0 Yellow
Litmus Red 5.0 - 8.0 Blue
Bromothymol blue Yellow 6.0 - 7.6 Blue
Thymol blue Yellow 8.0 - 9.6 Blue
Phenolphthalein Colorless 8.2 - 10.0 Pink
Thymolphthalein Colorless 9.4 - 10.6 Blue
Alizarin yellow R Yellow 10.1 - 12.0 Red
Some common indicators and their pK_ai (also referred to as pK_a) values are given in a table form. Since the table is an HTML file, we can not include the table in the DOS version, but the HTML version allows you to see this table below:

Name	Acid Color	pH Range of Color Change	Base Color
Methyl violet	Yellow	0.0 - 1.6	Blue
Thymol blue	Red	1.2 - 2.8	Yellow
Methyl orange	Red	3.2 - 4.4	Yellow
Bromocresol green	Yellow	3.8 - 5.4	Blue
Methyl red	Red	4.8 - 6.0	Yellow
Litmus	Red	5.0 - 8.0	Blue
Bromothymol blue	Yellow	6.0 - 7.6	Blue
Thymol blue	Yellow	8.0 - 9.6	Blue
Phenolphthalein	Colorless	8.2 - 10.0	Pink
Thymolphthalein	Colorless	9.4 - 10.6	Blue
Alizarin yellow R	Yellow	10.1 - 12.0	Red

There is a separate file for this, and it can also be accessed from the Chemical Handbook menu.

Example 1

Find a indicator for the titration of a 0.100 M solution of a weak acid HA (K_a = 6.2E-6) with 0.100 M NaOH solution.

Solutiion
First, you should estimate the pH at the equivalence point, at which the solution is 0.0500 M NaA. This is a hydrolysis problem, but the following method employs the general principle of equilibrium.

       A^-  +  H₂O  =  HA  +  OH^-
    0.0500-y          y      y

If we multiply the numerator and the denominator by [H⁺], rearrange the terms, note that [H⁺][OH^-] = K_w, and by the definition of K_a of the acid, we have the following relationship:

          y²      [HA][OH^-]  [H⁺]    K_w
       -------- = ---------- ---- = ----
       0.0500-y      [A^-]    [H⁺]    K_a

   y  =  ((0.0500)(K_w/K_a))^(1/2)
      = 9.0E-6

   pOH = -log [OH^-] = -log 9.0E-6
      = 5.05

   pH = 14 - 5.05
      = 8.95

Phenolphthalein in the table above has a pK_ai value of 9.7, which is the closest to the pH of equivalence point in this titration. This indicator is colorless in acidic solution, but a light PINK appears when the pH is > 8. The color becomes more INTENSE PINK as the pH rises. A parade of the color intensities is shown below:

___

The equivalence point is when the color changes most rapidly, not when the solution has changed color. Improper use of indicators will introduce inaccuracy to titration results.

Colors of an Indicator Solution

Indicators change color gradually at various pH. Let us assume that the acid form has a blue color and the basic form has red color. The variation of colors at different pH are shown below. The background color affects their appearance and our perception of them.

RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB
RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB RnB
_______

The long stretched color in the middle of the last line has equal intensity of BLUE and RED. If a solution has the color matching this color, the pH would be the same as the pK_ai of the indicator, providing that the conjugate forms of the indicator have the BLUE and RED colors.

Confidence Building Questions

There are numerous natural indicators present in the plants. The dye in red cabage, the purple color of grapes, even the color of some flowers are some of the example. What is the cause for some fruits to change color when they ripe?
Answer [H⁺] of the juice changes
Hint...
The changes in pH or [H⁺] causes the dye to change color if their conjugate acid-base pairs have different colors. There may be other reasons too. Do colors indicate how good or bad they taste?
Choose the true statement:
a. All weak acids are indicators.
b. All weak bases are indicators.
c. Weak acids and bases are indicators.
d. All indicators are weak acids.
e. An acid-base conjugate pair have different colors.
f. Any indicator changes color when the pH of its solution is 7.
Answer d
Hint...
Color change is a requirement for indicators.
Do all indicators change color at pH 7 (y/n)?
Answer No!
Hint...
Phenolphthalein changes color at pH ~9. Bromothymol blue has a pKn value of 7.1. At pH 7, its color changes from yellow to blue. Some indicators change color at pH other than 7.